Cognitive Bias & Motivation3–5 minBurden: MediumEMA: Baseline / infrequent

Personal Cue Photos (capture)

Participants photograph their own cues, such as the places where they usually drink or smoke, and their own control scenes with the phone camera. Picture Rating with the participant's own photos then shows these photos.

Cue reactivityPersonalised cuesCraving
Category
Cognitive Bias & Motivation
Typical duration
3–5 min
Participant burden
Medium
EMA suitability
Baseline / infrequent

Two steps in your study

Picture Rating with the participant's own photos needs a step in which the participant takes the photos first. The photos are taken once and then used by every rating task in the study.

  1. 1
    Personal Cue Photos (capture) (this task)Add it once, for example in the baseline survey. Participants take their photos, which stay on their phone.
  2. 2
    Picture Rating (participant's own photos)Add it wherever you measure cue reactivity, in the same or any later survey, with the same photo set name (default “cues”). Every rating uses the saved photos.
  • Only a finished set is used: the participant completes the capture step with Done. Photos taken before “Finish later” wait on the phone until then.
  • Photos of places take several sittings, because each place is photographed where the participant is: offer the capture survey on several days. Things at hand, such as the participant's usual drink, can be photographed in one sitting.
  • Taking the photos again (the capture step in a later survey) replaces the set; each rating trial records which set it used.
  • The photos are lost with a new phone, a reinstalled app or signing out, and deleted when the participant leaves the study. The rating task can then be skipped, and the data say so.

Read how the two steps work together

Try this task

Configure parameters and run an interactive preview exactly as participants will experience it. No data is recorded.

Configure preview

Adjust parameters below, then start the preview on the right.

Task parameters

Participants take their own photos with the phone camera: category A shows their cues, category B their own control scenes. Picture Rating (participant's own photos) then shows these photos. This follows the personal smoking environments paradigm, where smokers photographed 4 places where they smoke and 4 places they visit as often where they don't (Conklin et al., 2010; McClernon et al., 2016). Each photo is cropped to 4:3 and saved at 1200 × 900 pixels on the phone.

A rating task with the same photo set name shows these photos. A study usually needs one set; taking the photos again (e.g. in a later survey) replaces the set.

Category A (cues)

Category B (own controls)

8 photos. Conklin et al. (2010) asked for 4 places per category and used 3, keeping one as a buffer against unclear photos; here the app checks each photo and asks the participant to take an unclear one again, so every photo is used. Places are photographed where the participant is: a participant can stop with “Finish later”, and the photos taken so far stay on the phone until the step is opened again (e.g. a survey they open at each place, or a daily survey for a week, as in Conklin et al., 2010).

The photos stay on the participant's phone (as in the SWiPE app, Manning et al., 2021) and are deleted when they leave the study. The data hold each photo's id, category, size and measures, not the photo. Camera only by default: in the published procedures the photos were taken during the study. The quality check measures brightness (mean grey value), contrast and sharpness on a small copy and warns below 30 and 0.02; no published rule exists, so the warning is only a request to retake, and every photo's measures are stored for your own criteria. The app asks participants not to photograph people or anything that identifies them (Conklin et al., 2022).

Outputs: per photo its id, category, slot, camera or library, size, brightness, contrast and sharpness, any warning the participant overrode and how often it was retaken; and whether the set was finished.

3–5 minBurden: MediumEMA: Baseline / infrequent

This is a researcher preview. No participant data is recorded.

Simulated participant view

9:41

Personal Cue Photos (capture)

Participants photograph their own cues, such as the places where they usually drink or smoke, and their own control scenes with the phone camera. Picture Rating with the participant's own photos then shows these photos.

No data is recorded

Participant experience on smartphone

One screen per category with the researcher's instructions and a slot per photo. Each photo is cropped to 4:3 and shown as it will appear in the tasks; the app warns about a very dark or blurred photo, and the participant uses it or takes it again. “Finish later” keeps the photos taken so far for the next time the step opens.

When to use

When cue reactivity should be measured with each participant's own cues rather than standard pictures: personal smoking places gave larger craving differences than standard places (Conklin et al., 2010) and engaged the hippocampus where standard places did not (McClernon et al., 2016). Use it before Picture Rating (participant's own photos), in a baseline survey or over the first days of a study.

When not to use

Not a measure in itself: the step only collects the photos. Not for studies that cannot accept photos of participants' surroundings, and not when the cues must be identical across participants (use a validated picture set). Photos of a participant's own drinks or cigarette brand have no published rating procedure; own places are the established version.

How to use in a study

Keep the defaults of the personal smoking environments paradigm: 4 cue places and 4 control places that the participant visits at least weekly, using on most visits (cue) or rarely (control) (Conklin et al., 2010). The step fills in an example for alcohol; write your own instructions for your substance. Places are photographed where the participant is, so offer the step more than once (a survey they open at each place, or a daily survey for about a week, as in Conklin et al., 2010): “Finish later” keeps what they took. Photos stay on the phone unless you turn on Upload copies; in the published procedure staff checked every photo before use (McClernon et al., 2016), which needs copies. Add the photo paragraph of the IRB template to your consent form.

Researcher-configurable parameters

  • What participants photograph in each category, and the name of each category in the data
  • Photos per category (default 4 + 4, Conklin et al., 2010)
  • Own control photos (category B) or none, with control pictures from an image set in the rating task
  • Camera only (default) or also the photo library
  • Quality warning for very dark or blurred photos (default on; no published rule)
  • Upload copies of the photos (default off), encrypted with the responses in an end-to-end encrypted study
  • Photo set name, which links the step to the rating task

Outputs collected

  • Per photo: id, category, slot, camera or library, size, brightness (mean grey value), contrast and sharpness
  • Per photo: any quality warning the participant overrode, and how often it was taken again
  • Whether the set was finished, and the number of photos per category
  • With Upload copies: the photos, as task photos under Sensor Data

Interpretation notes

Own photos differ in content, lighting and quality from participant to participant, which standard sets control (Ekhtiari et al., 2022). Brightness, contrast and sharpness are stored for every photo so that they can be used as covariates. The photos are cropped from their centre, which can cut off part of a scene; the participant sees the cropped photo before using it.

Scientific evidence

  • Smokers who photographed 4 smoking and 4 nonsmoking places of their own showed a larger craving difference for personal than for standard places (d = 1.99 vs. 1.70; Conklin et al., 2010).
  • Personal smoking places raised craving more than standard ones and engaged the posterior hippocampus (McClernon et al., 2016).
  • Photos of a participant's own drinks can be used on a phone and stay on the device in the SWiPE approach-bias training app (Manning et al., 2021).